Table of Contents
As the New York Yankees visit the Toronto Blue Jays in a pivotal AL East clash, all eyes are on the sluggers to deliver. With both teams pushing for playoff positioning, this matchup offers value across the board in the player prop market—particularly in the total bases category.
Preview: Yankees vs Blue Jays Player Props
In this Yankees vs Blue Jays player props breakdown, we spotlight three key hitters: Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, and Jazz Chisholm Jr. Each has shown bursts of production in recent outings and sits with favorable over/under lines based on their season-long trends. Let’s get into the top Yankees vs Blue Jays player prop bets.
Yankees vs Blue Jays: Prop Bets
Aaron Judge Player Prop
Aaron Judge continues to be a force at the plate, averaging 2.61 bases per game—well above his Saturday line of 1.5. Although he’s had a recent cold stretch (0 bases in four of his last five), his upside remains elite, highlighted by an 8-base and 4-base outing just last week.
- Season Avg: 2.61 total bases
- High Performances: 8 bases (7/12), 4 bases (7/20)
- Line: Under 1.5 Bases (-125)
- Best Book: Caesars
If Judge gets anything to hit, he’s more than capable of clearing this line early in the game. Value is on the over at even money.
Cody Bellinger Player Prop
Bellinger enters the matchup with a season average of 1.98 bases, just above his line of 1.5 (+110). His recent output has been erratic—but with explosive upside. He logged 12 bases on 7/11 and 8 bases on 7/22, plus five multi-base games in his last 10.
- Season Avg: 1.98 total bases
- Monster Games: 12 bases (7/11), 8 bases (7/22)
- Line: Under 1.5 Bases (-135)
- Best Book: DraftKings
Given his recent power surge and favorable odds, Bellinger makes for a high-ceiling play in Saturday’s prop market.
Jazz Chisholm Jr. Player Prop
Jazz Chisholm Jr. carries a season average of 1.83 bases into this game with the line set at 1.5. While the overall average supports the over, he has been hit-or-miss in recent games—highlighted by an 8-base eruption against Seattle and a 4-base night versus Toronto.
- Season Avg: 1.83 total bases
- Recent Highs: 8 bases (7/9), 4 bases (7/22)
- Line: Under 1.5 Bases (-180)
- Best Book: DraftKings
This long-shot over is a high-risk, high-reward angle. Chisholm has demonstrated he can explode at the plate, and with a soft spot in Toronto’s rotation, the opportunity is there.
Get More Player Prop Picks Like Yankees vs Blue Jays
Have you tried the Juice Reel app? Besides the fact that it’s free to use, here are some of the features you’ll find in the app beyond prop bets for Yankees vs Blue Jays:
- Daily AI sports picks from our AI sports betting bot
- Community betting trends and consensus picks
- AI player prop bet predictions for every game so you can find the best PrizePicks today.
- Best odds across 300+ sports books (onshore & offshore)
- Automatic bet syncing across all your sports book bets
- Live bet tracker (like a stock portfolio ticker)
- Sell your sports picks and become a handicapper
Our website is great, but our app is better. The website is just a preview of what you can find in the free mobile app. Just the tip of the iceberg.
Download the free AI Sports betting app now to access all the sports betting data you can dream of. There is a reason Juice Reel has been crowned the “best sports betting tool”. Find out for yourself by clicking the button below.
