Best MLB Handicappers to Tail in 2025

Tired of guessing which baseball handicappers actually win? Juice Reel’s best MLB Handicappers Hub is your edge—100% transparent, data-backed, and synced to real sportsbook records.

Follow Real-Time MLB Betting Pros

This isn’t Twitter smoke. It’s the sharpest baseball picks, tracked live. Every MLB handicapper on Juice Reel syncs their account—so you see every pitch, every pick, every outcome.

100% Verified Records

We don’t do guesswork. Our system pulls bets straight from sportsbooks—no screenshots, no cherry-picking, no fluff when it comes to the best MLB handicappers.

Track ROI, win rate, streaks, and units
Find out who’s crushing MLB this week
Only follow baseball handicappers who prove it

Best MLB Handicappers For Picks

Tail sharp baseball bettors

Mike10693

+$17k Profit

Enjoy the parlays but tail all the singles too. Record in sports betting is irrelevant. Only profit is relevant. Most profitable sport can change on a monthly basis as I’m trying to find edges anywhere

Draco_Effect

+$7k Profit

U.S. Army Combat Vet turned degen. All plays backed by trend support and sharp analytics. I align with the data, not the hype. I’ve heard some say that I’m the best MLB handicapper is my strongest sport.

sandyy

+$5k Profit

Top down sides, totals, & game props. My best sport when it comes to being a handicapper is MLB. Bottom up player props. Decent volume of bets daily. Most active from 5am-9am & 3pm-5pm CST, but I ALWAYS sync as soon as I bet so you can get the best odds.

SherLock Bets

+$5k Profit

Baseball, football, college and some golf for good measure. Multiple units = higher confidence.

Best MLB Handicappers For Prop Bets

Tail sharp baseball bettors

Tailing The Sharps

+$9k Profit

Plays all sports but my best when it comes to being a handicapper is MLB. When I drop player props, make sure you have notifications so you can get the best odds.

Ajp9

+$8k Profit

Hello friends. Things to keep in mind. I am limited on several books so I often have to split my stakes between books. As such try to always read my comments. Unless otherwise stated in my bet comments assume each play is to risk one unit.

PropGAWD

+$5k Profit

I’ve been betting for over 10 years and my style is simple: I go where the profit is. I hunt down arbitrage opportunities in any market, big or small, and lock in guaranteed returns which makes me one of the best MLB handicappers.

BubsBets

+$4k Profit

Relentless edge-hunter, I dive into every sport, placing high-volume bets with precision. Always chasing value, I leverage data, sharp lines, and idsciplined strategy to grind out profit long term.

How it works

Start Following Top MLB Handicappers in Seconds

This is the best place to tail top rated MLB handicapper picks because it’s not built on hype—it’s built on data, receipts, and results. Every bettor on Juice Reel is required to sync their sportsbook accounts so you see every bet they’ve placed, every win, every loss.

1. Download the Juice Reel App

Start by downloading the Juice Reel app from the App Store or Google Play. Create your account so you can start exploring verified MLB handicappers.

2.Browse the Verified MLB Handicappers Marketplace

Once inside the app, jump into the Elite Bettor Marketplace where the top MLB handicappers are ranked by real betting data.

3. Filter by Sport, Performance, or Pick Type

Use powerful filters to find the right fit—whether you’re looking for sharp bettors in MLB, high-ROI baseball picks, or the hottest MLB prop handicappers.

4. Check Profiles, Records, and Stats

View detailed bios, see synced sportsbook records, analyze long-term performance, and know exactly who you’re tailing.

5. Follow the Best and Start Tailing Picks Instantly

Subscribe to the best MLB handicappers and receive push alerts when they place new bets. Start tailing winners immediately with confidence.

Testimonials

Join countless other sports enthusiasts who have turned their passion into a profitable business with Juice Reel.

"For a 'serious casual' bettor like me, I can't justify a subscription cost at this point, so I'm comparing free offerings here...and Juice Reel stands out. It has an outstanding UI for efficiently comparing stats vs lines in player props, team props, and so on. It also has fun features to keep you entertained like their juice points."

"Juice Reel made it so easy to start my sports handicapping business. Within weeks, I had a solid subscriber base, and the best part is, everything is completely transparent. My followers trust my picks because they can see my betting history in real-time!"

"This app has exceeded my expectations. Reading through the privacy policy, the owner has laid out strong protection for users. Finally, I do not need to keep everything on pen and paper to track all of my ongoing bets!"

"With Juice Reel, I finally feel like my sports betting skills are being recognized. The platform is user-friendly, and the transparency it offers sets it apart from everything else out there. I've been able to grow my subscriber base effortlessly, and the income is real!"

"I really like the look and feel of the app. The sportsbook sync is great and it really breaks down how you do. It’s a real eye opener!"

"I’ve tried other platforms, but nothing compares to Juice Reel. The ability to sync my sports books and have all my bets automatically tracked is a game-changer. Setting my own subscription price was easy, and I love how Juice Reel promotes my profile to potential subscribers."

Need Help?

FAQs

Have questions about following the best MLB handicappers on Juice Reel? We’ve got answers.

Tail the Best MLB Handicappers in the App Now

Join thousands of bettors using Juice Reel to tail the best MLB handicappers across the world.